Discuss: Why Star Wars? Why Star Trek?

The great debate– Star Wars or Star Trek?

starwarstrek

Both science-fiction titles are immensely popular, with a large part of that due to their loyal, crazy, and of course, nerdy fan base. But make no mistake, there is a difference between a Star Wars fan and a Trekkie. 

Andrew Dansby of the Houston Chronicle got me thinking with this article. In it, he highlights some differences between the two groups of fans, like for example:

The two Star worlds represent different strata of nerdiness, with Trek the fundamentalist faith of the two. Grown Star Wars fans might offer self-deprecating humor based on their fandom, but it doesn’t inspire the stigmatized reverence that Trek does.

Dansby goes on to explain that this may be because Star Wars, at heart, is a “dramatic space opera,” while Star Trek revels more in “harder science fiction.” (Although with this new movie, I sense the lines are being a little blurred). Of course, like anything in the sci-fi genre, both of these movies/shows depict thing far from reality. But the point is, when it comes down to what is more real, or what could be more real, Star Trek seems to come out on top. 

Here’s my take. While Star Wars ultimately functions as entertainment (really, really good entertainment I should say), Star Trek strives to do more than that– it creates a world within the real world that we experience. This explains why Trekkies take their shit so seriously. In a way, it is real to them– it defines a part of their lives. Star Wars fans, on the other hand, seem to understand that their beloved movies really do take place in a galaxy far, far away. (Which doesn’t mean they can’t be crazy fans either; I’m just talking in terms of their general attitudes).

But who knows. I have to admit, I am neither a huge Star Wars nor a huge Star Trek fan. I simply like both. Which is why I’m asking you, if you are indeed a big fan of Star Wars— why? Have you ever watched Star Trek? What about it doesn’t work for you? And if you are a Trekkie, what about Star Trek grabbed your attention? What do you think about Star Wars?

Advertisements

5 responses to “Discuss: Why Star Wars? Why Star Trek?

  1. raquelkraushar

    The new Star Trek movie has been #1 at the box office for two weeks straight!
    And an interview with the leading lady was featured in this week’s US Weekly

  2. kimberyknelson

    I’ve always thought that Star Wars was easier to track then Star Trek, not being a huge fan of either. Plus, Natalie Portman was so cute in the movies.

  3. star wars all the way. lol. there are just too many different star treks to keep track of. and idk star wars is just mesmerizing. its funny, epic, and it revolutionized filmmaking. i did see the new star trek tho and it was really good. (plus captain kirk was uber hot). 🙂

  4. STAR TREK! I like the characters more, especially the whole Spock-Kirk dynamic. (Spock > Kirk though, ahahaa)

  5. I prefer Star Wars… I grew up with it and it seems more modern to me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s